Guild of One-Name Studies
One-name studies, Genealogy
Study: Benefiel   
Variants: Benefield, Bennefiel, Bennefield, Benningfield
Category: 1 - A study where research using core genealogical datasets and transcriptions is in its early stages.
Contact: Dr Michael Bissell
Through a complicated set of family circumstances I was given the legal surname Bissell at birth but I was actually raised by my biological father Henry Robert Benefiel (1910-2000),pictured above, of whom I am very proud. Among the Benefiel family circle there was for years mild controversy about where the surname came from, speculation ranging as far as Italy. The family historian was a woman from Oklahoma named Evelyn Benefiel Stout who after years of research, wrote and self-published The Benefiel Families of Indiana and Their Descendants in 1983. This work documented some 25 separate family lines of Benefiels and spelling variants thereof with only speculation about how or even if they were connected to one another outside the United States. The mystery inherent in this stopping at the shoreline sparked my interest in genealogy. I became a fairly heavy user of Ancestry, FamilySearch and WikiTree, in which I started a Benefiel one name project several years ago now. It currently contains nearly 1100 profiles. These include profiles of Bedingfield families as a result of my strong belief that Benefiel is most likely a deviant spelling of Benefield, which in turn, is a late variant of the spelling of the ancient Bedingfield family. I am hoping through very careful work in the Guild to establish more firmly whether this connection exists or not. This will, I expect, include use of the somewhat extensive DNA testing I've had done over the years.
Registered variants are Benefield, Bennefiel, Bennefield, Benningfield, but this list is not exhaustive.
This is the fundamental question: is the origin of the Benefiel surname the individual usually cited as the earliest Norman French soldier Ogerus de Puyges, or indeed some one (or more) else?
George Eli Benefiel (1759–1832) Revolutionary War veteran: Private Cumberland County, Pennsylvania militia Captain James Patton's Company, Fourth Battalion; after the war, became a pioneer settler of Indiana.
Henry Robert Benefiel (1910-2000),my father, pictured above. He was a glider pilot with the 439th troop Carrier Division US Army Air Corps in World War II. He was initially stationed at RAF Upottery in Devon before being deployed in Operation Dragoon in southern France, followed by the Normandy invasion, Operation Market Garden in the Netherlands, and Operation Varsity into Germany. His unit also took part in the 'Battle of the Bulge'. He was awarded the Air Medal and the Bronze Star.
The Benefiel surname is virtually absent in England, but present in America. The Benefield, and Bedingfield surnames are present in both countries.
Distribution of a sampling of Benefiel, Benefield, Bedingfield and Bedingfeld surnames based on birth location in England and America.
Note that pin color denotes surname as follows: black = Benefield, white = Benefiel, red = Bedingfield, yellow = Bedingfeld, green = multiple spellings in one location.
Relative occurrence of surname variants in the FamilySearch.org database:
Firm Conclusions so far from DNA testing:
I. 37 marker Y chromosome analysis by Relative Genetics dated June 10, 2005 showed 100% match with brother Robert C Benefiel (Benefiel-156) whose surname has never been in doubt, confirms family information confided in Michael by his parents about his father's identity before their deaths in 2000. Later, on Ancestry DNA, 'DNA circles' based on autosomal DNA testing further corroborate this finding. I am a Benefiel.
II. DNA matches between individuals from surname subgroups with different spellings provide evidence that those subgroups are branches of the same family. This makes the fact that further BIG Y testing at FT DNA May 30, 2023 revealed the revised Benefiel BIG Y haplogroup to be R-BY45057 a match to within 8 short tandem repeats (strs) of Geoffrey James Bedingfield at adjacent haplogroup R-BY45059 which is regarded as being directly ancestral to RBY45057. This would appear to be suggestive in this regard.
23andMe
23andMe: ancestry-only DNA test from 23andMe Y-chromosome haplogroup: R1b1b2a1a1*Mitochondrial haplogroup: J1c2 GEDmatch ID: M112651 I have confirmed at dozens of DNA cousins to date. ethnicity estimates: -23andMe: 53.4% Britain and Ireland 14.9% France and Germany 4.4% Scandinavia 0.2% Finland 2.9% Southern Europe 0.2% Middle East and North Africa 0.1% Trace regions
Test details URL: https://www.wikitree.com/index.php?title=Special:DNATests&u=11507277&id=1
Added by Michael Bissell --Benefiel. Last edit on Feb 14, 2019.
Autosomal DNA Test Details & Connections: Benefiel family members that have been connected theoretically to Michael (Bissell) Bissell --Benefiel's autosomal DNA test. This includes all blood relatives within eight degrees of separation — up to sixth great-grandparents and out to third cousins.
[in each entry the data elements are: Name; Degrees of separation from Michael Bissell; Predicted % identical DNA sequence information; Date of birth]
Last edited: Feb 14, 2019
AncestryDNA
Y-chromosome haplogroup: R1b1b2a1a1*
Mitochondrial haplogroup: J1c2
GEDmatch ID: M396023
Ethnicity estimates:
84% Great Britain
6% Scandinavia
5% Western Europe
4% Trace regions
AncestryDNA Maternal Lineage: Mitochondrial mitochondrial DNA test from Ancestry.com
Test Details URL
(now discontinued).
AncestryDNA Paternal Lineage: Y-chromosome DNA test from Ancestry.com (now discontinued).
Test Details URL https://www.wikitree.com/index.php?title=Special:DNATests&u=11507277&id=3.
Added by Michael Bissell --Benefiel. Last edit on Oct 20, 2015
And connections: View family members connected through Michael (Bissell) Bissell --Benefiel's Ancestry Y-chromosome. This list traces Michael (Bissell) Bissell --Benefiel's direct-line paternal ancestry, finding the earliest-known paternal grandfather,Anthony Benefield b. 1647 Earliest-known paternal ancestor: View carriers of Anthony's Y-chromosome in descendant chart form. and then going down all of this ancestor's direct male lines. The hypertexts on these names connect to the WikiTree profile of each person when clicked.
Addison Benefiel b. Jun 1862
Albert Benefiel b. 26 Mar 1872
Allan Benefiel b. 4 Aug 1903
Allen Benefiel b. 4 Apr 1860
Alpha Benefiel b. 8 Aug 1883
Alvin Benefiel b. 22 Mar 1916
Andrew Benefiel b. 18 Dec 1917
Archie Benefiel b. 6 Jan 1878
Arthur Benefiel b. 12 May 1910
Arthur Benefiel
Arthur W. Benefiel b. 1843
Austin Benefiel b. 16 Jun 1859
B. Benefiel b. 1871
Ben Benefiel
Benjamin Benefiel b. 2 Feb 1844
Benjamin Benefiel b. 25 Jan 1876
Bennett Benefiel b. Aug 1850
Bernard Benefiel b. Jan 1888
Bert Benefiel b. 22 Sep 1884
Bob Benefiel b. 29 Nov 1829
Bruce Benefiel b. 14 Aug 1932
Calvin Benefiel b. 15 Jan 1918
Cecil Benefiel b. 7 Dec 1900
Chaney Benefiel b. Feb 1862
Charles Benefiel b. 28 Aug 1867
Charles Benefiel b. 3 Jan 1868
Charles Benefiel b. 2 Feb 1905
Charles Benefiel b. 20 Oct 1870
Charles Benefiel b. 11 Dec 1872
Charles Benefiel b. 19 Nov 1883
Charles Benefiel b. 25 Jun 1899
Charles Benefiel b. 12 Apr 1910
Living: Charles Benefiel b. 15 May 1967
Charley Theodore Benefiel b. 4 Feb 1887
Chester Benefiel b. 8 Mar 1907
Chester Arthur Benefiel b. 13 Feb 1884
Living: Chuck Benefiel b. 7 Jan 1943
Clarence Benefiel b. 27 Feb 1877
Clarence Benefiel b. 24 May 1893
Clarence Benefiel b. 2 Mar 1870
Clarence C Benefiel b. Nov 1882
Clark Benefiel b. 1822
Clark Benefiel b. 15 Mar 1882
Claude Benefiel b. 1 Oct 1903
Curtis Benefiel
Dale Benefiel b. 14 Mar 1916
Daniel Benefiel b. 1839
Daniel Benefiel b. 14 Apr 1863
Dennis Benefiel b. 30 Jul 1945
Dewey Benefiel b. 12 Apr 1907
Dixon Benefiel b. 5 Nov 1862
Don Benefiel b. 12 Jun 1927
Donald Benefiel b. 17 Aug 1911
Donald Benefiel b. 30 Jan 1929
Doyle Benefiel b. 17 Dec 1913
Eagon Benefiel b. 15 Sep 1862
Earl Benefiel b. 6 Jun 1883
Earl Benefiel b. 26 Mar 1932
Edgar Benefiel b. 1873
Edmund Benefiel b. 27 Mar 1910
Edmund Benefiel b. 8 Jun 1933
Edward Benefiel b. 13 Jul 1915
Edward Benefiel b. 8 Jul 1883
Edwin Benefiel b. 14 Oct 1857
Elmer Benefiel b. 1915
Enoch Benefiel b. 28 Dec 1833
Ephraim Benefiel b. 5 Oct 1866
Ernest Benefiel b. 22 Jun 1882
Floyd Benefiel b. 15 Feb 1923
Francis Benefiel b. 22 Jan 1838
Francis Benefiel b. 16 Nov 1830
Francis Benefiel b. Jul 1859
Francis Benefiel b. 25 Dec 1853
Frank Benefiel b. 4 Aug 1860
Frank Benefiel b. 24 Feb 1862
Frank Benefiel b. 23 May 1874
Frank Benefiel b. 3 Nov 1886
Franklin Benefiel b. 15 Jul 1843
Fred Benefiel b. 27 Dec 1897
Fred Benefiel b. 7 Jan 1910
Fred Benefiel b. 29 Apr 1905
Fred Benefiel b. 23 Nov 1903
Living: Frederick Benefiel b. 21 Apr 1936
Friedley Benefiel b. 13 Jan 1868
George Benefiel b. 25 Dec 1759
George Benefiel b. 8 Jan 1795
George Benefiel b. 1817
George Benefiel b. 14 Sep 1833
George Benefiel b. 9 Feb 1845
George Benefiel b. 28 Apr 1845
George Benefiel b. 15 Dec 1818
George Benefiel b. 2 Apr 1875
George Benefiel b. Jan 1864
George Benefiel b. 10 Oct 1876
George Benefiel b. 29 Jul 1844
George Benefiel b. 19 Aug 1869
George Benefiel b. 25 Oct 1892
George Benefiel b. 3 Feb 1904
George Benefiel b. 22 Aug 1894
George Benefiel b. Dec 1874
George Benefiel b. 24 Dec 1884
George Benefiel b. 5 Feb 1932
George Benefiel b. 24 Jan 1912
George A. Benefiel b. 1837
Glen Benefiel b. 1 Aug 1902
Golden Benefiel b. 3 Jun 1890
Guss Benefiel b. Jun 1870
Guy Benefiel b. 5 Jul 1886
H Benefiel b. 1860
Hardia Benefiel b. 27 Mar 1886
Harley Benefiel b. 1 Oct 1880
Harold Benefiel b. 16 Apr 1908
Harry Benefiel b. 14 Apr 1907
Harry Benefiel b. 22 Aug 1866
Hartsel Benefiel b. 29 May 1894
Harvey Benefiel b. 11 Aug 1853
Henry Benefiel b. 15 Jan 1899
Henry Benefiel b. 9 Mar 1890
Henry Benefiel b. 29 Jun 1904
Henry Benefiel b. 17 May 1910
Henry Benefiel b. 25 Aug 1927
Herman Benefiel b. 11 Aug 1885
Hiram Benefiel b. 9 Dec 1801
Hiram Benefiel b. 1839
Hiram Benefiel b. 12 Apr 1835
Hiram Benefiel b. 12 Oct 1822
Hiram Benefiel b. 11 Mar 1851
Hiram Benefiel b. 12 Nov 1853
Homer Benefiel b. 7 Apr 1886
Homer Benefiel b. 22 Jan 1891
Horace Benefiel b. 23 Apr 1894
Howard Benefiel b. 24 Oct 1915
Hubert Benefiel b. 18 Aug 1917
Hugh Benefiel b. 27 Mar 1892
Hugo Benefiel b. 4 Jan 1895
Ira Benefiel b. 25 Nov 1885
Isaac Benefiel b. 28 Jul 1901
Isaac Benefiel b. 30 Apr 1827
Isaac Benefiel b. 5 Nov 1850
Isham Benefiel b. 14 Sep 1837
Israel Benefiel b. 29 Oct 1806
Israel Benefiel b. 10 Mar 1822
J. B. Benefiel b. 22 Apr 1847
Jack Benefiel b. 10 Dec 1891
Jack Benefiel b. 17 Feb 1914
Jacob Benefiel b. 16 Mar 1876
Jacob Benefiel b. 1901
Jacob Benefiel b. 1823
Jacob Benefiel b. 1 Jul 1866
James Benefiel b. 11 May 1806
James Benefiel b. 27 Dec 1853
James Benefiel b. 25 Nov 1829
James Benefiel b. 28 Feb 1817
James Benefiel b. 12 Nov 1853
James Benefiel b. 21 Jul 1825
James Benefiel b. 27 May 1827
James Benefiel b. 1831
James Benefiel b. 1841
James Benefiel b. 16 Jun 1872
James Benefiel b. 6 Aug 1853
James Benefiel b. 23 Jul 1863
James Benefiel b. 1869
James Benefiel b. 20 Apr 1861
James Benefiel b. 5 Sep 1836
James Benefiel b. 8 Aug 1846
James Benefiel b. 26 Aug 1871
James Benefiel b. 2 May 1878
James Benefiel b. 14 May 1920
James Benefiel b. 1920
James Benefiel b. 17 Sep 1895
James Madison Benefiel b. 16 May 1829
Jason Benefiel b. 26 Feb 1828
Jasper Benefiel b. 18 May 1859
Living: Jay Benefiel
Jesse Benefiel b. 11 Dec 1868
Jesse Benefiel b. 26 Oct 1800
Jesse Benefiel b. 27 Nov 1833
Jesse F. Benefiel b. Apr 1833
Jesse Martin Benefiel b. 8 Oct 1835
Jim Benefiel b. 24 Aug 1918
Jim Benefiel b. 12 Apr 1925
Joel Benefiel b. 25 Sep 1909
Joel Benefiel b. 20 Dec 1867
John Benefiel b. 1760
John Benefiel b. 1 Oct 1793
John Benefiel b. 2 Dec 1789
John (Benefield) Benefiel b. Jan 1795
John Benefiel b. 18 Jan 1820
John Benefiel b. 19 Jan 1832
John Benefiel b. 1830
John Benefiel b. 17 Nov 1836
John Benefiel b. 19 Jan 1817
John Benefiel b. 8 Sep 1845
John Benefiel b. 4 Feb 1820
John Benefiel b. 1869
John Benefiel b. 17 Sep 1852
John Benefiel b. 15 Dec 1853
John Benefiel b. 12 Jun 1849
John Benefiel b. 13 Dec 1847
John Benefiel b. 8 Sep 1871
John Benefiel b. 1843
John Benefiel b. 8 Mar 1871
John Benefiel b. 24 Dec 1896
John Benefiel b. 28 Dec 1875
John Benefiel b. 21 Sep 1912
John Taylor Benefiel b. 1835
Jonas Benefiel b. 1865
Joseph Benefiel b. 21 Jan 1879
Joseph Benefiel b. 25 Aug 1882
Joseph Benefiel b. 30 Jan 1892
Joseph Benefiel b. 26 Apr 1912
Kearney Benefiel
Kenneth Benefiel b. 10 Mar 1890
L. Benefiel b. 1872
L. G. Benefiel b. 2 Jan 1907
Laurence Benefiel b. 29 Jan 1927
Laurence Benefiel b. 6 Aug 1892
Lawrence Benefiel b. 8 Feb 1875
Lawrence Benefiel b. 20 May 1913
Lawrence Benefiel b. 20 Jul 1917
Lawson Benefiel b. Feb 1836
Leander Benefiel b. 10 Oct 1835
Leon Benefiel b. 22 Feb 1892
Leroy Benefiel b. 31 Oct 1873
Leslie Benefiel b. 19 Feb 1913
Levi Benefiel b. 5 Oct 1833
Levi Benefiel b. 27 Mar 1823
Lewis Benefiel b. 4 Jan 1817
Lewis Benefiel b. 13 Jan 1864
Lloyd J Benefiel b. 1909
Locie Benefiel b. 27 Nov 1901
Louis Benefiel b. 20 Jan 1909
Louis Benefiel b. 6 Jan 1856
Louis Benefiel b. Apr 1860
Lucius Benefiel b. 8 Nov 1852
Lynn C Benefiel b. 1907
Marcellus Benefiel b. 1850
Max Benefiel b. 18 Aug 1916
Medford Benefiel b. 1899
Michael Benefiel b. 23 Nov 1937
Living: Michael Benefiel
Millard Benefiel b. 4 Oct 1858
Moris Benefiel b. May 1856
Morton Benefiel b. 5 Oct 1862
Newton Benefiel b. Sep 1860
Noble Benefiel b. 11 Oct 1889
Odus Benefiel b. 12 Nov 1894
Oliver M Benefiel b. 1863
Orme Benefiel b. 3 Mar 1869
Oscar Benefiel b. 12 Dec 1882
Oscar Benefiel b. 25 Jun 1894
Oscar Benefiel b. 1912
Otis Benefiel b. 3 Jan 1892
Otto Benefiel b. 1878
Owen Benefiel b. 3 Mar 1869
Paul Benefiel b. 23 Jan 1922
Paul Benefiel
Living: Paul Benefiel b. 23 Jan 1953
Perry Benefiel b. Aug 1872
Peter Benefiel b. 1853
Peter Benefiel b. Mar 1856
Philip Benefiel b. 25 Jun 1923
Phillip Benefiel b. 1867
Phillip Benefiel b. 24 Sep 1917
Phillip Benefiel b. 6 Jul 1955
Ralph Benefiel b. 1921
Ray Benefiel b. 4 Aug 1927
Raymond Benefiel b. 7 Apr 1896
Raymond Benefiel b. 11 Jul 1902
Raymond Shrock Benefiel b. 11 Jul 1894
Richard Benefiel b. 14 Sep 1929
Richard Benefiel b. 9 Jun 1921
Richard Benefiel b. 1810
Robert Benefiel b. 1770
Robert Benefiel b. 29 Nov 1787
Robert Benefiel b. 1788
Robert Benefiel b. 15 Oct 1791
Robert Benefiel b. 25 Jan 1837
Robert Benefiel b. 20 May 1827
Robert Benefiel b. 22 Sep 1829
Robert Benefiel b. 18 Feb 1821
Robert Benefiel b. 28 Oct 1828
Robert Benefiel b. 1839
Robert Benefiel b. 20 Apr 1839
Robert Benefiel b. 1871
Robert Benefiel b. 21 Jan 1848
Robert Benefiel b. 23 Oct 1857
Robert Benefiel b. 23 Jun 1887
Robert Benefiel b. 14 Nov 1891
Robert Benefiel b. 31 Jan 1929
Robert Benefiel b. 18 Jun 1949
Robert Benefiel b. 25 Feb 1952
Robert Benefiel b. 8 Nov 1958
Living: Robert Benefiel b. 17 Sep 1970
Robert Gallatin Benefiel b. 30 Nov 1820
Robert N. Benefiel b. 1825
Rollin Benefiel b. Jul 1886
Roscoe Benefiel b. 30 Dec 1880
Ross Benefiel b. 8 May 1877
Roy Benefiel b. 9 Jan 1891
Roy Benefiel b. 5 Dec 1888
Roy Benefiel b. 12 Sep 1919
Samuel Benefiel b. 1771
Samuel Benefiel b. 11 May 1806
Samuel Benefiel b. 23 Feb 1816
Samuel Benefiel b. 21 Feb 1819
Samuel Benefiel b. Dec 1862
Samuel Benefiel b. 27 Oct 1857
Samuel Benefiel b. 1862
Samuel M. Benefiel b. 1831
Snowden Benefiel b. 5 Nov 1872
Squire Benefiel b. 25 Nov 1850
Stanley Benefiel b. 15 Nov 1871
Stewart Benefiel b. 1803
Ted Benefiel b. 17 Mar 1917
Theodore Benefiel b. 9 Feb 1828
Theodore Benefiel b. 1 Nov 1849
Thomas Benefiel b. 1856
Thomas Benefiel b. 30 Dec 1897
Thomas Benefiel b. 24 Sep 1952
Ulysses Benefiel b. 14 May 1865
Wallace R Benefiel b. 1921
Walter Benefiel b. 21 Mar 1879
Walter Alonzo Benefiel b. 1889
Wilbur Benefiel b. 27 Jan 1887
Willard Benefiel b. 1874
William Benefiel b. 10 Jul 1901
William Benefiel b. 18 Apr 1895
William Benefiel b. 10 Sep 1896
William Benefiel b. 18 Jun 1873
William Benefiel b. 20 Jun 1885
William Benefiel b. 13 Jan 1873
William Benefiel b. 26 Sep 1923
William Benefiel b. 10 May 1926
William Benefiel b. 7 Mar 1909
Living: William Benefiel b. 1953
William Benefiel b. 14 Apr 1791
William Benefiel b. 1801
William Benefiel b. 14 Aug 1801
William Benefiel b. 6 Jun 1797
William Benefiel b. 13 Feb 1842
William Benefiel b. 17 Dec 1837
William Benefiel b. 7 Nov 1836
William Benefiel b. 1849
William Benefiel b. 2 Aug 1850
William Benefiel b. 5 Feb 1834
William Benefiel b. 14 Sep 1842
William Benefiel b. 4 Jun 1820
William Benefiel b. 20 Jul 1830
William Benefiel b. 4 Jul 1831
William Benefiel b. 4 Sep 1877
William Benefiel b. 11 Dec 1858
William Benefiel b. 16 Apr 1872
William Benefiel b. 14 Jan 1846
William Benefiel b. 19 May 1859
William Benefiel b. 20 Feb 1845
William Benefiel b. 29 May 1869
William Benefiel b. 16 Sep 1868
William Benefiel b. 12 Jun 1852
William Benefiel b. 29 Jan 1862
William Benefiel b. Apr 1874
William Benefiel b. Sep 1847
William Benefiel b. 29 Sep 1854
William Benefiel b. 9 Dec 1850
William Benefiel b. 30 Jun 1852
William Benefiel b. 6 Sep 1873
William B. Benefiel b. 8 Dec 1828
William Claud Benefiel b. 1884
William Franklin Benefiel b. 1860
William Fred Benefiel b. 1892
William Henry Harrison Benefiel b. 1825
Wilson Benefiel b. 18 Nov 1802
Wilson Benefiel b. 21 May 1859
Anthony Benefield b. 1647 Earliest-known paternal ancestor: View carriers of Anthony's Y-chromosome in descendant chart form.
Frank Benefield b. 1 May 1874
George Benefield b. 1721
James Benefield b. 1765
Robert Benefield b. 1740
Thomas Benefield b. 1865
William Benefield b. 19 Jul 1763
William Benefield b. Apr 1857
John Benningfield b. 1695
Living: Grahame Bissell b. 9 Sep 1983
Living: Michael (Bissell) Bissell --Benefiel b. 5 Mar 1947
Relative Genetics
Test Details
Y-chromosome haplogroup: R1b
Number of markers that were tested: 37
MitoYDNA ID: Not entered
37 marker Y chromosome analysis by Relative Genetics dated June 10, 2005 showed 100% match with brother Robert C Benefiel (Benefiel-156) confirming family information confided in Michael by his parents before their deaths in 2000. Later, on Ancestry DNA, 'DNA circles' based on autosomal DNA testing further corroborate this finding. I am a Benefiel.
Test details URL: https://www.wikitree.com/index.php?title=Special:DNATests&u=11507277&id=11
Added by Michael Bissell --Benefiel. Last edit on Oct 31, 2015.
AncestryDNA paternal lineage
https://www.wikitree.com/index.php?title=Special:DNATests&u=11507277&id=3.
Family Search
Family Tree DNA
23 and me
WikiTree
MG Bissell profile:
https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Bissell-517
compact family tree:
https://www.wikitree.com/treewidget/Bissell-517/5
WikiTree research:
Benefiel Name Study
Benefiel/Benefield/Bedingfield Name Study